Monday, March 2, 2020

Trying Thrice - Loose Parts & Learning Invitations

One of the best things about being a specialist teacher is that you get the opportunity to try lessons more than once, with different classes. This is helpful because, after reflecting on the lesson's successes and failures, I can modify / improve the lesson and try again.

I see three kindergarten classes for library time and media literacy instruction. A couple of weeks ago, I taught a simplified version of this lesson, posted on the AML website, about the 2020 winner of the Best Animated Short Film, "Hair Love".

I wanted to dive in a little more into some of the ideas and themes from this fantastic film. I also wanted to try out some of the approaches and techniques advocated in the Kindergarten Additional Qualification course that I'm currently taking with Gail Bedeau and Kenisha Bynoe, especially loose parts and learning invitations.

These aren't "100% ideal learning invitations" (I said this to Gail or Kenisha who questioned me on this - I don't mean that they aren't perfect, but that they deliberately don't completely follow some of the guidelines for creating learning invitations as we've been shown in our course.)

First Try - Monday, February 24, 2020 with "K2"

This was my first attempt at organizing some learning invitations designed on my own. The hard part was that it was during the second period of the afternoon, which meant I couldn't set up in advance. (We were using the tables for another purpose with a different class immediately before this lesson.) The set-up felt very rushed, even though I made plans so that at least two of the adults in the room could be free to fix the items up strategically by having the students re-watch the film. The lucky part was that Jennifer Balido-Cadavez, amazing ECE teacher, actually had loose parts that she was able to quickly bring from her kindergarten class to the library to supplement my meager supplies. (I wish I could buy more but Phase 6 of ETFO's current work-to-rule stipulations states that we are to temporarily refrain from using our own personal funds to supplement our classrooms.)

I have a paper called "A Guide to Planning An Invitation for Learning" (created by Kenisha Bynoe and Angelique Thompson) and the second step is to select a text, photo or artifact. I chose a trophy (artifact) for one of my invitations and the actual book "Hair Love" (text) for the second invitation. I was nervous about my third media text choice. I picked my cherished puppet doll. I've noticed that toys aren't often (or ever?) part of a learning invitation, but I was uncertain how to explore hair without something with hair. (Jen Cadavez solved this within days, but more on that later.) I also wondered if only having a single head of hair would cause disagreements between the children. I debated with myself and others and brought out a "second head". This invitation, of all of the ones I attempted to design, felt the most limited in scope and possibilities.

The third step to planning an invitation for learning is to develop a question. This is the hard part for me. The question has to be open-ended, offer many possibilities for play and learning, and more - all of this, with the chance that students might not attempt to read the question and that it wasn't 100% required to read the question to the students. The questions were "How might we celebrate?" / "How might we help Zuri?" / "How might we show love?"




I know that, in my Kindergarten AQ course, we aren't getting around to the topic of pedagogical documentation until March 11, but I was determined to try and observe and document (via anecdotal notes, photos and videos) as best as I could. Thanks go to SC and Mrs. Cadavez for quickly capturing as much as they could.

Three big things that I noticed were:
1) Many of the students had no clue what to do at the learning invitations. Some just stared and froze.
2) The students who chose the "hair-focused" learning invitation ignored the young black figure in favor of the adult white blonde figure. When I made a suggestion that all four students presently at the invitation didn't have to limit themselves to one figure, they just looked at me. I discretely rushed over to Mrs. Cadavez to share my observation and ask her what to do. We "traded" spaces to watch and once she started playing with and interacting with the black doll, then other students followed her lead.
3) At the hair centre, the students really enjoyed digging through the supply bin and discovering some objects I hadn't even considered them using. It gave me a lot of insight into their extensive background knowledge and schemas.

This is a birthday cake from the "celebrate" invitation


Second Try - Thursday, February 27, 2020 with "K1"

As you can imagine, I spent a lot of time discussing with SC and Mrs. Cadavez discussing what we saw and what our next steps should be for K2. In the meantime, I had my AQ class on Wednesday, February 26. The guest speaker was Angelique Thompson and her topic was "Comprehensive Literacy Programming in Play". She said a lot of fantastic things during her presentation, but one of the most powerful for me was helping students learn how to interact playfully with loose parts.


Thankfully, the class I was going to try this with for the second time had their kindergarten media period immediately after lunch - which meant I had time to carefully set up the learning invitations in a much less-rushed, more thoughtful way. I was going to pull the blonde "Barbie head" out of the invitation, but Mrs. Cadavez asked me not to; she said it could be an interesting comparison and wondered if the other class would react in similar ways to her students.

For "How might we help Zuri?", I added iPads for potential photo documentation (plus, in the book and video, Zuri uses some sort of electronic tablet device to look at her mother's vlogs to understand how to style her hair). I tried to minimize the supply box's presence (but was still interested to see if they wanted to explore its contents, so I left it there). For "How might we celebrate?" I was much more deliberate in how I set items up, with symmetry, patterns, and objects. (I desperately wanted the containers to match, but didn't have enough of the same type.). For "How might we show love?" all objects had containers.

We also tried a modified version of Angelique's steps to becoming comfortable with using loose parts for play. (She said to Observe / Think / Explore / Create / Document. Her guiding questions were "What do you see? What can you do with it? How might you use the materials?" and I used the first and third questions with the students.) I recorded their ideas on a paper I left at an empty table.





There's no such thing as "wrong play" (at least, I hope not) but this time around, things seemed to go smoother. To my great relief, both dolls were used as part of the play, although a certain subset of girls showed an obvious preference for the blonde head. I loved that both boys and girls gravitated to all three invitations. The presence of the iPads had an odd effect - one of the students took one, turned it on and started flipping through it. When I asked her what she was going to do, she said "Go on YouTube". I'm not sure if it was connected to the film, when Zuri looks up her mom's videos, or if it was just a "this is what we do on an iPad" reaction.

J put clips in her own hair

Built at the celebrate area



Third Try - Friday, February 28, 2020 with "K3"

My concern for this class was that it is a smaller group without an Early Childhood Educator present; this meant one less adult present to help with pedagogical documentation. (We have a SNA with this class but she had her hands full with the student who needs her help and couldn't spend time taking notes.) I made fewer changes to the learning invitations but still tweaked things a bit. Once again, this class occurred immediately after lunch so I had time to carefully set up the learning invitations. I tried to make the writing tools more interesting in the "How might we help Zuri?" by placing some of the hair bobbles in the clear cup with the pencils. I also placed some of the hair ties in the black puppet's hand.





I wish I had video taped or captured the audio when I gave this group a tour of the learning invitations. One student in particular loudly and delightedly made many positive comments and connections between the invitations and the film had just watched, saying things like "That doll looks just like the girl in the movie! And look, there's the book that looks just like the movie! And oh, the markers are in a pattern - see, it's red, blue, red, blue!"

I asked SC to watch the "How might we help Zuri?" invitation while I attended to the other two. It was hard to capture everything, because there were SO many examples of the students demonstrating the four frames (Belonging and Contributing / Self-Regulation and Well-Being / Literacy and Mathematics Behaviours / Problem Solving and Innovating). SC told me that she was so touched by how sweetly some of the students treated the puppet in particular.

Only one student at the "How do we show love?" invitation struggled. "What do I do?" she asked. Another student arrived at the invitation and promptly started making a heart. By the end, she created four hearts with four different sets of materials. The student who was initially befuddled took inspiration from this other child and made her own heart.



A's picture combined chalk and jewels

D, with 4 different types of hearts

S's patterned heart, inspired by D
What also wowed me was the ingenuity and problem solving of K and D. They weren't satisfied with the limited colours of wipe-off markers I had set up in the "How might we celebrate?" learning invitation - so K grabbed my bin of Sharpies that I had elsewhere. At first, I freaked out a bit - Sharpies don't come off whiteboards easily! Then, I thought I shouldn't limit them, so reluctantly I gave back the Sharpies I initially confiscated. K and D tried to erase it but it didn't come off, but then D yells out, "Wait, see this works! Colour with one of these markers on top and it'll come out!" (And it did - not perfectly, but it did!)

Remember the first group, K2? Jennifer Cadavez was busy contemplating how to address this potential bias around hair types.

Not only did she create a learning invitation (which was, no offence to me, way more awesome than mine), but she CO- CREATED it WITH THE STUDENTS! I asked her to tell me all about it and she texted me this description:

The students helped me co-create this learning invitation. After our media class, we found a book in our class library about hair. I began to set up the table for the invitation and one student said, "What are you doing?". I said, "I am planning to make a loose parts invitation for the class." The student began to start cutting pieces of coloured yarn. "If you spray paint your hair, it can be green like this string." "If you use pipe cleaners and twirl it around your finger, it can be like the curl."

Talk about being a responsive educator! Jennifer helps me and inspires me so much, and not just me. The loose parts learning invitations and the observations helped shape SC's upcoming kindergarten media lessons (because she'll be teaching 100% of the time for the next two weeks).

Monday, February 24, 2020

Celebrating my student teacher - respectfully

Aviva Dunsiger understands me. In a blog post she wrote in response to last week's entry of mine, she said,
Diana’s posts are always complex, and usually involve a few different topics connected together in the most wonderful of ways
That's very perceptive. I actually make an effort to combine several thoughts swirling in my head together because I only write once a week. Thinking and writing about events helps me sort things out, and for the reader, it means that if someone isn't drawn in by one of the topics, they might be by one of the others.

My original intention (based on the last sentence of last week's blog) was to talk about my new student-teacher. As is my usual practice, I told her my plans and asked if it would be okay if I wrote about her and shared some photos of her on my blog. She gave some parameters, which I have respected in this post.

That gave me a new tangent to explore - what Jennifer Casa-Todd calls creating "a culture of consent". (Read her blog about the topic at https://jcasatodd.com/normalizing-a-culture-of-consent-on-social-media/).

Thank you Farah Wadia for taking this photo of me
As you can imagine, I'm pretty comfortable with sharing information and images of myself online - although I don't share everything. (This post of mine, from 2017, talks about what I choose NOT to share.). Having said that, I think it's important to still check in with people, even "public people", to see if they are okay with you posting things featuring them. I don't want to pat myself on the back, but during OLA Super Conference, I took what I felt was a fantastic photo of three wonderful people (Lisa Noble, Amanda Williams, and Angela Stockman) enjoying some aromatherapy. After taking a few shots, I asked Lisa, Amanda, and Angela if they were comfortable with me sharing the photo on Twitter. Angela was taken a bit aback. "I've never been asked about this - thank you" was (an approximation of) her response.

I was surprised that she was surprised - and disappointed too. It must be very common that the act of obtaining consent is completely ignored. I've written about consent before (in 2018) and my views on the issue still remain consistent. Ask. If people ask for boundaries or limits, listen to them. When it comes to children, ask them too, but err on the side of caution - they may not be aware of how long-lasting an image, video, or comment linked to their name might remain. (That's why the photos I took of students reading for I Read Canadian Day have no faces. Sonia Singh, who also took photos of her students, also respected the balance between her students' privacy and their desire to be captured on film and celebrated.)



And if you forget and post without permission, own up to the error, check in with the person, and make changes if necessary. For instance, I posed a tweet and a photo about a wonderful colleague of mine, Farah Wadia, and the interview she gave during our strike on Friday. I didn't check with her first; thankfully when I contacted her, she gave me her consent to keep the tweet up. (Sorry for the slip-up, Farah!)


This leads me back to my student-teacher. She mentioned that in her Faculty of Education training, they were cautioned repeatedly about using social media. (The teacher-candidates are quite aware of the Ontario College of Teachers guidelines around the use of electronic communication and social media - I just wish the take-away for many of them wasn't/isn't to avoid it completely.)

I know how important it is to have a good associate teacher / host teacher. I was in the Concurrent Education program at the Faculty of Education at York University. I had three year-long placements with three different locations during my teacher formation time. Most of those experiences were extremely positive, but I contemplated quitting the Faculty of Education because of one of those placements. While in that particular teacher's room, I felt like I couldn't do anything right. I was belittled and treated like a second-class citizen. I wasn't allowed to sit in the "teacher's chair" until my month-long teaching block in May. Some of the habits I developed as coping mechanisms and/or part of that teacher's advice took years to undo. I told myself that if I was ever fortunate to be a host teacher, I would be different.

SC is a Year 2 Faculty of Education student at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education at the University of Toronto. When she graduates, she will have her Junior-Intermediate qualifications and she plans on gaining her Primary qualifications shortly afterward. I have learned so much from SC already, and it's only been a week! She was the one who introduced me to a term I had never heard before (TPR - Total Physical Response). SC explained to me that  ELL teachers use this technique to increase understanding for their students and she noticed that some of the ways I talk to my students include TPR techniques. I'm going to have to investigate this further. I had no idea.

SC helping a student with tech for a project

There are many things I really appreciate about SC. She likes and responds to feedback and is keen to try new things. Simultaneously, she is aware of and able to establish her comfort level and isn't afraid to say "no" or "not yet". Boundaries are good and healthy!

SC reading a book to a kindergarten class

SC is a hard worker who has stepped up quickly to the demands of teaching in a school library space, reading several books from the Forest of Reading list for 2020 so she can be prepared to chat with junior and intermediate division students like I do.


SC is prepared and her first whole-class lesson (a STEAM session with Grade 2s) went well. I can hardly wait to see the cardboard cabinets that the students make with her.


There's a lot of information to take in, especially because most of SC's prior placements have been in Grade 6-8 and she is now interacting with K-8. I've noticed that she is working on building rapport with as many students as she can, which is no easy feat. The current work-to-rule situation makes it doubly challenging, because we can't talk leisurely after school or plan / set-up early in the morning.

As a new host teacher, I have other concerns too, none of which centre on SC. I worry that this unusual circumstance (i.e. SC's first teaching week was only three days, because of Family Day on Monday and the province-wide strike on Friday) will deprive SC of some of the full experience of being at my school. I also worry that SC will feel the need to model her teaching on mine - my teaching is a reflection of my training and identities and although I stand by the methods and techniques I use, I hope SC doesn't employ them just because I do. Then there's my modified teaching priorities - I'm doing a lot less information literacy and research skills with the upper grade students than I've done in the past, because we need to use the time during the instructional day to address the literacy goals related to the Forest of Reading. This may give SC a skewed image of the school library as "just about books and reading". I'll need to let go of my worries and go with the flow. I hope SC enjoys her placement as much as I already have.


Monday, February 17, 2020

The Clutter Conundrum and Decision-Making Fatigue

(Happy Family Day to those in Canada who celebrate!) This week has been a challenging one, and not just because of the strike action. Learning, unlearning, and relearning is really difficult.

The most recent piece of the pie was that while I was picketing, a health and safety inspector came to visit my teaching space. I received three violation notifications for infractions that I needed to deal with ASAP. This stressed me out, even though my caretaker reassured me that this was not catastrophic news. My principal even said that I could indirectly thank H&S for spurring me into action - because I spent the Parent-Teacher Interview day on February 14 consulting with various experts and completely re-configuring the school library layout. Visual-spatial skills are not my forte; I can't imagine new set-ups clearly unless I see them. Big thanks to Michael, Jessie, Renee and others for providing their suggestions and feedback. In order to address the concerns expressed in the health and safety report, we revamped the way the school library is organized. This was tough. (I actually didn't take a lot of photos during the process so far, because I needed to be totally present and documenting had to take a back seat.)



(These are the only two photos I took. The first image with the blank wall used to be where my graphic novel / comic collection shelves were located. Now it will be where my interactive white board goes. My comics area is elsewhere. I also stripped the bulletin boards. The second image withe the bare board has trim. More on that below.)

I need to remind irregular readers of this blog that I am not a tidy person. (See https://mondaymollymusings.blogspot.com/2018/08/i-got-n-on-my-report-card.html) My husband has famously said "Just because you buy organizational tools does not make you an organized person". So a day of cleaning and rearranging was not my idea of paradise, even though I will appreciate the end result.

Compounding this is the cognitive dissonance and conflict I feel as I'm learning things in my Kindergarten AQ course. I started the course on January 15, 2020 (as I mentioned in this blog post) and it's been fascinating. It's also been challenging a lot of my prior knowledge and ideas around play, resources, purchases, question prompts, and the class environment. I've been talking about my learning and the struggle I'm having with some of the ideas with other educators. They've been very supportive and cautioned me to not "throw the baby out with the bathwater". The biggest internal struggles have been around "clutter" and set-up. I read two articles that was part of our assigned readings for Invitations for Learning (they are https://www.childcareexchange.com/library/5015738.pdf and https://www.edonline.sk.ca/bbcswebdav/library/Curriculum%20Website/Kindergarten/Resources/Core/creating_invitations_for_learning.pdf) and both made a point about "orderly, beautiful arrangements". My inner devil's advocate keeps yelling things at me like "Who has time?" and "That feels too artificial and Pinteresty". However, these points about aesthetic considerations for displays have rationales and research behind them so I cannot dismiss them entirely and I know part of my internal debate stems from my concern with changing how I teach. (e.g. I know that big bins of stuff lead to dumping everything out, because I've seen that behaviour, but what if supplies are insufficient in these artful displays?) In a reading on the learning environment (especially http://ocw.umb.edu/early-education-development/echd-440-640-eec-language-and-literacy-course/learning-module-1/module-11/consider%20the%20walls.pdf), there were serious objections to clutter and to commercially prepared decorations. I agree, but I also sob inside when I consider how much money I've spent on posters and trims over the course of my career. This means that there are so many things I need to get rid of, including things I've collected (not hoarded) for school use over the years.



(These are two of the learning provocations that our instructors set up for us on February 12. I really struggled with the top one, because I didn't understand the question ["What is the rhythm in your skin?"] at all. Once I finally figured out it was more along the lines of "How might you make music?", I was slightly more ready to try but my initial attempts involved smashing everything in the display on its side and off the table. Sorry I hit you Emily, although it was just once and by accident.)

I can weed books. It's weeding toys that can be hard. Toys have faces and sentimental attachment. I still remember when my parents threw out Barley the Bison and a few other stuffed animals we played with as children. I understand points made about using loose parts instead of toys because toys can prescribe the play in certain ways, may limit creativity, and might indirectly reinforce stereotypes around gender and class. Yet, I also know how much fun students have with playing with the toys I have and that they can use toys in unpredictable ways. Which toys stay and which toys go?

And this leads me to the second part of my blog post title. I looked it up and saw a quote that claims that the average classroom teacher will make more than 1 500 educational decisions every school day, which works out to 4 decisions per minute. (The source for this was https://www.teachervision.com/too-many-tasks-not-enough-day) Other articles say that average people make 35 000 decisions a day, and 226 of those are just about food. (The source for this information was https://raywilliams.ca/neuroscience-can-help-us-make-better-decisions/). Your "decision tank" gets empty after 75 decisions, according to this article. With the extra responsibility of being one of the three school union stewards, I find that it's tiring to make important decisions, especially when they impact several people and/or need to be made relatively quickly. Where do we picket? Where should we meet for the attendance sign-in and sign-out on province-wide strike days when there's a big crowd? How should we coordinate the selection of translators for interview day when certain activities constitute struck work under our work-to-rule guidelines? Which toys do I get rid of, and where do they go?

Thankfully, I've come up with one decision (as I lay in bed, thinking things over when I should have been sleeping) that will make me feel a bit better about the decision to purge some of the unnecessary clutter.


Wednesday, February 19, 2020 is #IReadCanadian Day. I've signed up our school for this event. It's simple: everyone read a Canadian book for just 15 minutes.





My plan for my school is to announce that if a class reads a Canadian book/author/illustrator for 15 minutes on February 19, the students are allowed to choose a stuffed animal (with an "I Read Canadian" tag on it) for free. If you take a photo of you reading that Canadian book that your teacher-librarian can use on social media, then you can have two! I plan on sorting through the tons of stuffed animals at school and categorizing them into ones I want to keep for personal reasons, ones to keep for teaching purposes (limited to one bin) and ones to give away to my students for I Read Canadian Day. I hope that by consoling myself with knowing that the stuffed animals will be going to the homes of my students for a good cause that it won't feel like I am "throwing them out". It's a decent compromise decision and will hopefully reduce some of the clutter. Maybe I'll even get my new student-teacher to help. (New student-teacher? More on that probably in next week's blog post!)

Monday, February 10, 2020

What's it like to strike



I wasn't sure I was going to write this post, because other people have done a better job with similar themes - the current actions by Ontario educators in response to the actions of the Ontario government.

There are more examples, but you can see Doug Peterson's compilation list or samples from:

Kyleen Gray (@TCHevolution on Twitter) - https://teacherevolution.me/2020/01/24/dear-ontario-parents-dont-stress-about-withheld-report-cards/

Will Gourley (@WillGourley on Twitter) https://heartandart.ca/?p=8425

This is my twenty-third year of teaching and only the third time I've ever not been in class due to political job action.

The First Time


The first time was in 1997. I started the school year as an LTO and had just recently accepted a permanent full-time contract position at another school. It was about Bill 160. As has been pointed out online, it technically wasn't a strike. It was two weeks long. My sign in the photo says "We do not like when Tories lie. We do not like it, teachers cry" with a Cat in the Hat drawing. To quote my own tweet ...

This was October or November of 1997. I desperately needed the break and staff bonding, even though it was a big financial hit as a new teacher. As Doug will assuredly note, I was into costumes even back then (my hat and mask [not seen here] matched my sign)

The Second Time





The second time was December 18, 2012 - a one-day action related to Bill 115. My home-made signs say "It's not about the money, honey. Bill 115 stings our rights" (to match my Winnie the Pooh costume) and "Do you hear the teachers sing? Singing the song of angry men. It is the music of a people who want unjust bills to end" (using a Les Miz reference).

Currently





Here we are, for the third time. So far, it's been January 20, February 6, 7 and will be February 11 and 12. I hope that things can be resolved. My signs (to match my leopard / cheetah suit) say "No limits to class size? A CATastrophe" and "Education cuts are CATastropic".

See any patterns? There are a few similarities. A lot has to do with unfair legislation. A lot has to do with students' learning conditions (because teacher working conditions are directly related to student learning conditions). And it always seems to generate an opportunity for me to wear a costume and make my own signs.

But what's it actually LIKE to strike? It's a mix of emotions and thoughts, both positive and negative.

The Positive Parts


  • The camaraderie can be very uplifting. By walking the picket lines with other educators, you are reminded that you aren't alone. You get to know colleagues better while you walk and talk.
  • It's good exercise. I'm exceeding my Fit Bit step goal regularly.
  • The support (especially this time around) by the general public has been very encouraging. The honking horns, kind words, gifts of food and drinks have been wonderful

The Negative Parts

  • I miss my students! Even though I must commend the union on how they've tried their hardest not to make anything unpleasant for the parents or students (i.e. we didn't withdraw extra-curriclular activities until Phase 5 of our Work-to-Rule plan), being away from them is hard. We'd rather be teaching.
  • It's exhausting! Three hours of pacing the sidewalks outside in the cold takes a different kind of energy from the seven hours of teaching inside. I've been going to bed earlier but it still doesn't shake the persistently tired feeling.
  • It hurts financially. For anyone who claims it's about compensation ... I'm losing more money being on strike. (As a single-income family, it makes an impact.) The unions (and it's all four Ontario education unions - ETFO, OSSTF, OECTA and AEFO) don't take these actions lightly.

So Why Strike?


(Image says "Reg 274 works for schools and teacher because hiring is no longer about 'who you know' - it's based on qualifications and experience.")


(Image says "Quality Public Education for All Ontario Students: Ontario has one of the best public education systems in the world, providing high-quality education for every student regardless of where they live. The government must prioritize students and our schools. It's time to reverse funding cuts and invest in public education."


(Image says"Kindergarten Works: Extensive research has shown that Ontario's current Kindergarten model, which includes a full-time certified teacher and a designated early childhood educator (DECE) works best for students. Created by education experts and based on international research, Kindergarten makes Ontario a global leader in early childhood education."


(Images says "Addressing Violence in Our Schools: Violence in our schools is a symptom of broader issues facing the education system, including larger classes, a lack of resources and student supports and fewer staff to meet the varied needs of students. Schools need more guidance counsellors, child and youth workers, mental health supports and timely assessments for students who need them"


(Image says "Support for Students with Special Needs: The funding model for special education programs is based on a predictive model rather than student needs. Funding is disconnected from what is happening in elementary classrooms and the needs of students in our schools."


Our class sizes are larger than they should be. Not only do we need to maintain the Grade 1-3 Primary class size cap, we need to instate class sizes for our Junior and Intermediate classes too.

I really hope that the government will come back to the bargaining table and negotiate in good faith. We are not being secretive about our requests. I'm prepared to strike for as long as we have to do so. I want to publicly thank our union executives (led by Sam Hammond) for working so hard for teachers, students and parents. It's not easy, but good things don't always come easy.


Thursday, February 6, 2020

OLA SC 2020 Day 4 aka TMC6 Reflections

Someone has done this already, and to be brutally honest, done it better. Jordan Graham was the guest blogger for TMC6 and she was a machine ... or a force of nature ...or whatever metaphor you choose to share to indicate the incredible quantity and quality of reflections on Treasure Mountain Canada 6 she produced in such a short period of time. (Jordan even captured quotes from the award winners during their acceptance speeches - how did she DO that?) I truly do not know how she was able to listen, synthesize, summarize, and write (with photos) during the actual symposium.

Still, it's worth me sharing my $0.02.

Saturday, February 1, 2020 - 7:45 a.m.

Another early morning (but my first night's sleep in the hotel where I didn't wake up during the night) and breakfast with the participants of TMC6. I couldn't resist doing some final "red-vest" duties with Emily Burns, directing people to OLBA Bootcamp and answering questions. I will miss working with you Emily!

Saturday, February 1, 2020 - 8:30 a.m.

The TMC spotlight speaker was Garfield and Laura Gini-Newman. Their paper was a real brain-buster for me. I read their paper, "Powerful Instruction and Powerful Assessment: The Double Helix of Learning" before the symposium and this was part of my response:

As someone who was fed and consumed heartily from the Wiggins & McTighe backwards design model, this new way of planning, thinking and assessing is going to take some unlearning and relearning for me. I've got to ask myself some tough questions, like "does this assessment inspire learning?". I think I will need my PLN to help me digest this even more and see what it actually means in practice for me.

I like Jordan's paraphrase about how the Gini-Newmans are encouraging us to rethink assessment:

Central to this paper is the distinction between assessment, "to sit alongside a learner," and evaluation, "to judge a learner."  The thinking is about how we move from sitting in judgement to sitting alongside, and how feedback can become guidance.

 Saturday, February 1, 2020 - 9:30 a.m.

Anita Brooks-Kirkland spoke about The Eric Walters School Library Summer Lending Challenge research paper that she and Carol Koechlin wrote. For those of you who have not yet read the paper, it's lengthy but extremely thorough. I really need to think about their suggestions. One was to reduce the amount of extra hoops or bureaucratic steps needed to make it happen. I was one of those schools that arranged a special note, translated into Chinese and English, to explain and gain permission. Am I at the stage where I can get rid of that yet? I'm not sure.

Saturday, February 1, 2020 - 10:30 a.m.

Time for table talks! Seven of us that had contributed papers to Treasure Mountain Canada 6 gave a one minute promotional blurb to encourage participants to come to our tables to discuss the papers.

The photo below includes Rebeca Ruibo, Alanna King, Beth Lyons, and me, Diana Maliszewski (#5).

Presenter line up

I didn't take pictures during my table talk, but I did take notes. I wanted to treat my session as a discussion forum where I could learn from the participants just as much as they might learn from me.

Promo slide for my talk


In the first round, I had Pam, Alison, Sarah, Jonelle, and Lisa at my table and I want to thank them for their contributions. I like how Pam admitted that she wasn't a "manga person" and that led her school's manga club to make purchasing recommendations that she often followed (with series research by her). I like how Jonelle used an online wish list and included benefits like being the first to borrow the book if you suggested that the school library buy it. I also like Jonelle's future plans to include the leadership class in making some more purchasing decisions for the school library. I appreciated Lisa's work with her school in teaching students with an equity lens so they can develop the criteria for examining the school library collection. I also admire how Alison said she want to make how she chooses books for the school library collection more visible and transparent.

In the second round, I had Leigh, Erin, Toni, Jess, Dawn, Christie and Jane, and once again, I want to thank them for their contributions to our discussion. They had such good, important points to make. When circumstances prevent you from actually taking students to buy books at book stores or with approved board vendors, there are other options you can employ. Christie uses a mailbox of requests (and it's fascinating to see that half of the suggestions are titles already in her school library's collection). Jess uses wish lists and asks students to put in their requests. Leigh wondered about the possibility of using the Scholastic flyers as ways for students to give input. After considering how selecting from lists or recommendations would be similar or different from in-person shopping (while being mindful of the equity issues that are part of those actions), the group also talked about the kinds of evidence or proof that could be collected to show that involving students makes a different. Suggestions included circulation statistics, surveying parents to see if they noticed any behaviour or comments from their children after the experience, asking teachers to identify students disengaged with reading and invite the class teachers to observe and record any changes in those students after such a trip, and meta-cognitive data. 

I'm sorry I didn't get a chance to hear the other morning table talks. They sounded good!


Once again, big thanks to Jordan Graham for capturing the essence of two of the other morning table talks - you can read them here: https://tmcanada.blogspot.com/2020/02/table-talk-snapshots-round-1.html

Saturday, February 1, 2020 - 11:30 a.m.

Leigh online
We had a virtual spotlight speaker present at Treasure Mountain Canada - Leigh Cassell. Leigh spoke about her paper regarding "wise practices" (not best practices - a significant difference) when using video conferencing. I really appreciated how Leigh followed up my request for names of critical scholars involved with justice-oriented, intercultural experiences by providing a list in her presentation. No excuses for me now not to become more acquainted with these researchers. My favourite line from their paper was this one:

"Learning about, with, and from people of varying cultural practices requires educators to help students reject ethnocentrism while better understanding their own cultural practices of which they may lack consciousness."

Jordan Graham summarized Leigh's talk here - https://tmcanada.blogspot.com/2020/02/spotlight-speaker-leigh-cassell.html and Carol had us do a building connections activity just before lunch.

Reaching 3 types of educators (I forgive whoever took my cell)


Saturday, February 1, 2020 - 1:15 p.m.

Our afternoon, whole-group spotlight speaker was Deborah Dundas, from The Toronto Star. She shared her work doing her version of the Cooperative Children's Book Center, School of Education, University of Wisconsin-Madison's investigation into Diversity in Children's Books. Deborah was very patient with our flurry of questions and I'm so glad to hear that she'll be doing a follow-up survey. 


Deborah speaks

Jordan's reporting of this spotlight can be found at https://tmcanada.blogspot.com/2020/02/spotlight-speaker-deborah-dundas.html

Saturday, February 1, 2020 - 1:45 p.m.

More table talks! This time I was lucky enough to listen instead of speak. Jordan attended two sessions that I did not. You can read her impressions at https://tmcanada.blogspot.com/2020/02/table-talk-snapshots-round-2.html

Getting shadows to work with you
The first talk I attended during this round was Jane Dennis-Moore's "If you Give a Kid a Camera: Participatory Visual Literacy in the LLC". She had so many great things to share. Students learn through discovery, especially with photo-taking; allow them to explore. Photography isn't just taking photos, but looking at photos. You don't have to have a fancy SLR camera to involve your students with taking photos, although when you trust students with a camera like this, it wows them and they rise to the challenge. It builds a sense of excitement, is invigorating, empowering increases confidence and encourages risk-taking. We participants asked where we might start. Jane suggested a "Who am I?" task, based on taking photos using different angles of students. If you have limited number of iPads, borrow the grade iPads. Taking photos with Chromebooks is possible but not ideal because hits hard to get close. Jane recommended using the devices collaboratively; for instance, creating a photo booth centre involves several roles. Jane's favourite photo prompt is "do a self-portrait that is NOT a selfie that reveals something about you". 

Christine's photo


Jane's session also involved taking as many different angles of a small object as possible. Here are all of the shots I took.in a BeFunky photo collage.





The second session during this round that I attended was by Jonelle St. Aubyn, called "The Human Library at the Luise Arbour Secondary School Library Learning Commons". I've wanted to replicate this at my school for years and Jonelle explained how she did it, both at her table talk and in her paper. She said that some of her students are quite sheltered (i.e. they are not allowed to take public transit on their own) so this event was helpful to change their perspectives. It's tricky to contact individuals who might make great "human books" because the philosophy is that no one gets paid for this encounter. Thankfully, Jonelle had a lot of contacts. The most popular "human book" was their school's NPU officer - questions asked included things like "What do I do if I get pulled over by the police?" Some groups were more interested in hearing the person's story than asking them questions, like the heart transplant recipient. It was important to have representation and role models. Jonelle recommended listing multiple parts of identities (e.g. LGBQT + testicular cancer survivor / South Asian + artist). She emphasized that this event is not meant to be a career fair. Her advice is to start planning early because visitors need to have a criminal background check.


Saturday, February 1, 2020 - 2:55 p.m.

The "Big Think" is a David Loertscher speciality - getting participants to synthesize, prepare next steps, and think beyond. Why not involve other specialist teachers in co-planning, co-teaching, and co-assessing? What if the music teacher worked in conjunction with a classroom teacher? Or a phys-ed specialist? What might be possible if it was a School Learning Commons and not just a School Library Learning Commons? Each group brainstormed areas inspired by various papers presented during the symposium. (Jordan writes about this session here - https://tmcanada.blogspot.com/2020/02/the-big-think-david-loertscher_1.html) 



We ended the day with a surprise present for the "godmothers of Canadian school libraries" and Canadian School Libraries Chair and Vice-Chair, Anita Brooks-Kirkland and Carol Koechlin. 


Lots of great connections were made, both near ... (as in TDSB, my own school board)


and far ... (as in other provinces, like my friends in Manitoba and our Nova Scotia connections)



Let the learning live on!